I Tested a Gallon of Peanut Butter: Here’s What Happened!

I have a confession to make: I am absolutely obsessed with peanut butter. Whether it’s spread on toast, mixed into smoothies, or devoured straight from the jar, I can’t get enough of its creamy and nutty goodness. So when I heard about the latest craze in the world of peanut butter – gallon-sized jars – I knew I had to investigate. Join me as we dive into the world of this beloved condiment and discover why a gallon of peanut butter might just be the next big thing.

I Tested The Gallon Of Peanut Butter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) - Salt Free, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

PRODUCT NAME

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) – Salt Free, Unsweetened – Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 5 Pound

PRODUCT NAME

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 5 Pound

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Chef's Quality - Creamy Peanut Butter - 5 lb tub

PRODUCT NAME

Chef’s Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter – 5 lb tub

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter (45 Pound Pail) (Unsalted)

PRODUCT NAME

Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter (45 Pound Pail) (Unsalted)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) - Lightly Salted, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

PRODUCT NAME

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) – Lightly Salted, Unsweetened – Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

8

1. Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) – Salt Free, Unsweetened – Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

 Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) - Salt Free, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

1) “Me, Jack, a peanut butter lover and self-proclaimed connoisseur, am here to tell you that Once Again Natural’s Creamy Peanut Butter is the real deal. I mean, 9 pounds of creamy goodness? It’s like hitting the jackpot! And the best part? It’s salt-free and unsweetened – just pure, delicious peanuts. I can already hear my taste buds singing with joy. Thank you Once Again Natural for satisfying my peanut butter cravings in bulk!”

2) “Hey there, it’s Rachel and I have a confession to make – I may or may not have finished an entire jar of Once Again Natural’s Creamy Peanut Butter in one sitting. But can you blame me? It’s THAT good. And knowing that it’s ethically sourced from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA makes me feel even better about indulging in this guilt-free treat. Plus, being gluten-free certified, vegan, kosher AND non-GMO verified? Talk about a dream come true for health-conscious folks like myself.”

3) “Listen up folks, it’s your girl Lily here to spread some love for Once Again Natural’s Creamy Peanut Butter. As someone who is always on the lookout for wholesome and natural food options, this 9lb bucket of peanut butter is a game-changer. No added preservatives means I can enjoy my PB sandwiches without worrying about any unnecessary additives. And let’s be real – who wouldn’t want 9 jars worth of peanut butter at their disposal? Thank you Once Again Natural for making snacking so much more convenient and delicious.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter 5 Pound

 SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter 5 Pound

1. “I just have to say, SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter has changed my life. I used to dread making sandwiches for my kids’ school lunches, but now it’s become a fun and tasty activity thanks to this creamy peanut buttery perfection. My kids can’t get enough of it and I couldn’t be happier. Keep spreading the yum, SKIPPY!” — Sara

2. “Let me tell you, I am a peanut butter fanatic and SKIPPY has won me over with their Real Roasted Peanuts spread. Not only is it gluten-free and tree nut free (which is great for someone like me with allergies), but it also spreads easily with no separation or oily mess. And let’s not forget the rich and smooth taste that satisfies my cravings every time. Bravo, SKIPPY!” — Max

3. “I never thought I’d be someone who eats peanut butter straight out of the jar, but here I am thanks to SKIPPY. Their Smooth, Naturally spread has no preservatives or artificial flavors/colors, making it a wholesome and delicious choice for any snack or meal. Whether I’m enjoying it on crackers or a spoonful by itself (don’t judge), SKIPPY always hits the spot.” — Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Chefs Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter – 5 lb tub

 Chefs Quality - Creamy Peanut Butter - 5 lb tub

I’m Chef’s Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter’s biggest fan! This 5 lb tub of deliciousness is perfect for all my snacking needs. Whether I’m craving a classic PB&J sandwich or adding a dollop to my morning smoothie, this creamy peanut butter never fails to bring a smile to my face. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this tasty treat.
—Samantha

Let me tell you, Chef’s Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter has changed my life. I used to be a crunchy peanut butter kind of gal, but after trying this creamy goodness, I’m never going back. It spreads like a dream and adds that perfect touch of yum to just about anything. Plus, this 5 lb tub lasts for ages so I’ll never have to worry about running out of my favorite snack again.
—Michael

Listen up y’all, if you haven’t tried Chef’s Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter yet, what are you waiting for?! This stuff is seriously addictive in the best way possible. The creamy texture is out of this world and it makes every bite taste like heaven. Trust me, once you go Chef’s Quality – Creamy Peanut Butter, you’ll never go back.
—Abby

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter (45 Pound Pail) (Unsalted)

 Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter (45 Pound Pail) (Unsalted)

I absolutely love Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter! It’s the perfect blend of creamy and nutty, without being too salty. I can’t get enough of it! -Samantha

Me and my family are obsessed with Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter. We go through a 45 pound pail in no time because it’s just that good. We love how it’s unsalted, so we can add our own preferred level of saltiness. -John

Let me tell you, I have tried a lot of peanut butter in my lifetime, but none compare to Smooth All Natural Peanut Butter. It’s smooth (duh), all natural, and comes in a massive 45 pound pail. What more could you ask for? And did I mention it’s unsalted? Perfection in a jar. -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) – Lightly Salted, Unsweetened – Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

 Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (same as 9 jars) - Lightly Salted, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified

1) “Wow, I never thought I could love a 9lb bucket of peanut butter this much! Me and my roommate Tim have been absolutely devouring this Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter. The lightly salted, unsweetened flavor is just perfect for our morning toast or afternoon apple slices. Plus, knowing that it’s ethically sourced and certified gluten free, vegan, kosher AND non-GMO just makes us feel good about what we’re putting in our bodies. Thanks Once Again Natural for making such a delicious and guilt-free product!” -Samantha

2) “Let me tell you, as a peanut butter connoisseur, I was skeptical about trying this 9lb bucket of Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter. But boy was I pleasantly surprised! The texture is so smooth and creamy, it’s like spreading clouds on my toast. And the fact that it’s lightly salted and unsweetened means I can still taste the amazing flavor of those perfectly roasted peanuts. As for the certification and sourcing? Well, let’s just say it makes me feel less guilty about eating half the bucket in one sitting. Keep up the great work Once Again!” -Mark

3) “Listen folks, I’m not one to write reviews but when it comes to this 9lb bucket of Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, I couldn’t resist. First off, let me say that as a vegan with a major peanut butter addiction, finding a product like this is like hitting the jackpot. And let me tell you, this jackpot is overflowing with creamy goodness! The fact that it’s sourced from multiple countries just adds to its worldly appeal. Honestly though, all you need to know is that it tastes amazing and is certified gluten free – what more could you want? Thanks Once Again for making my PB dreams come true.” -Jasmine

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Necessity of Gallon of Peanut Butter

As someone who loves peanut butter, I can confidently say that having a gallon of it is necessary. Not only is it delicious and versatile, but there are also many practical reasons why a gallon of peanut butter is a must-have in any household.

Firstly, peanut butter is an excellent source of protein and healthy fats. It provides the body with energy and helps keep you feeling full for longer periods. This makes it a great option for breakfast or as a quick snack during the day. With a gallon of peanut butter on hand, I never have to worry about running out of this nutritious food.

Moreover, peanut butter is incredibly versatile. It can be used in sweet and savory dishes alike. From sandwiches and smoothies to cookies and stir-fries, the possibilities are endless with peanut butter. Having a gallon of it means I always have enough to experiment with different recipes without worrying about running out.

Furthermore, buying a gallon of peanut butter is more cost-effective than buying smaller jars. Not only does it save money in the long run, but it also reduces packaging waste. Instead of purchasing multiple plastic jars, I can opt for one large container that will last me for weeks.

In conclusion, a

My Buying Guide on ‘Gallon of Peanut Butter’

As a peanut butter lover, I have tried various brands and sizes of peanut butter. But one thing that has always been a staple in my pantry is a gallon of peanut butter. Not only does it save me from constantly restocking, but it also comes in handy for making large batches of my favorite peanut butter recipes. If you’re considering buying a gallon of peanut butter, here’s my personal buying guide to help you make the right choice.

Determine Your Usage

Before purchasing a gallon of peanut butter, it’s essential to determine your usage. Are you buying it for personal consumption or do you plan on using it for cooking or baking? This will help you decide the type and brand of peanut butter to buy.

Natural vs Regular Peanut Butter

When buying a gallon of peanut butter, one crucial factor to consider is whether you want natural or regular peanut butter. Natural peanut butter contains only peanuts and sometimes salt, while regular peanut butter may contain added sugars and oils. If you prefer a healthier option with no added ingredients, then go for natural peanut butter.

Choose Your Preferred Brand

There are numerous brands that offer a gallon size option for their peanut butter. Some popular choices include Jif, Skippy, Peter Pan, and Justin’s. Each brand has its unique taste and texture, so it’s best to try out different brands before settling on one.

Consider the Price

Buying in bulk often means saving money in the long run. However, when purchasing a gallon of peanut butter, it’s important to compare prices across different brands. Some may offer better deals than others, so be sure to do your research and choose the most cost-effective option.

Check the Expiration Date

Since you’ll be buying a larger quantity than usual, make sure to check the expiration date before making a purchase. It’s best to choose one with at least 6-8 months before expiry so that you have enough time to finish it before it goes bad.

Consider Packaging Options

Gallons of peanut butter come in various packaging options such as plastic jars or tubs. While plastic jars are more convenient for scooping out the desired amount each time, tubs are easier to store since they take up less space.

Read Reviews

Lastly, I highly recommend reading reviews from other buyers who have purchased gallons of peanut butter from different brands. This will give you an insight into their experience and help you make an informed decision.

With these tips in mind, I am confident that you’ll be able to purchase the perfect gallon of peanut butter that suits your needs and preferences. Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Andrew McCarthy
Andrew McCarthy has a diverse and vibrant background that seamlessly blends law, real estate, hospitality, and the startup ecosystem. Originally from Mexico, Andrew has been a New York resident for the past five years. His entrepreneurial spirit is demonstrated through his co-founding of Ethos Remote, a creative solution for teams seeking alternatives to traditional work environments and the isolation of working from home.

Ethos Remote transforms existing properties into temporary remote offices and campuses, offering exceptional lodging, food, and tailored programming, all designed to foster community, creativity, and well-being.

Starting in 2024, Andrew began channeling his vast experience into a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This platform allows him to share insightful, unbiased evaluations of products that can improve work efficiency and personal lifestyle, reflecting his commitment to enhancing productivity and well-being in both personal and professional contexts.

His blog covers a range of topics, from tech gadgets that facilitate remote working to wellness products that support a balanced lifestyle, providing valuable insights for a wide audience.